Young Woman and the Sea Review: Daisy Ridley Stuns and Earns Your Tears in This Beautifu

 Posted on September 8, 2024  |  8 minutes  |  1607 words  |  Aldo Pusey
Critics Pick

Lovely and riveting at every turn, Joachim Rønning's Trudy Ederle biopic is a winning celebration of feminine perseverance and sisterhood.

“They don’t make ‘em like this anymore,” we wistfully say these days when praising skillful mainstream movies, ones that remind us of a past when Hollywood used to stir us more regularly through moving original films.

There is truth in that overused nostalgic acclaim, even though few movies actually deserve it as much as Joachim Rønning’s (“Kon-Tiki”) classically glorious “Young Woman and The Sea,” a defiantly big-screen, consistently enthralling biopic that both earns one’s genuine tears, and inspires everyone of all ages to dream a little bigger, go a little further.

For the film’s wondrous rebel Trudy Ederle (a graceful, commanding Daisy Ridley), who became the first woman to swim across the treacherous 21-mile English Channel in 1926, that big dream at first wasn’t even becoming a legitimate athlete, let alone a history-making pioneer. Born to German immigrant parents of modest means in the Coney Island of 1905, Trudy just wanted to swim, whichever way she would be permitted. But respectable girls weren’t really supposed to play around and waste time in splashy pools, and the young Trudy — beautifully portrayed by Olive Abercrombie in a brief but memorable performance — wasn’t allowed in community pools anyway, having barely survived a highly contagious case of measles.

Related Stories

concert crowd and stock arrow VIP+

New Live Music Data Suggests Cautious Optimism

2Be3

Prime Video France Unveils Sexy Originals: Rebecca Zlotowski's 'Glamsquad,' '2be3' Series on French Boy Band and Pickup of 'Escort Boys' Season 2 (EXCLUSIVE)

Affectionately adapted from Glenn Stout’s book “Young Woman and the Sea: How Trudy Ederle Conquered the English Channel and Inspired the World” by Jeff Nathanson (of “Catch Me If You Can” and Barry Jenkins’ upcoming “Mufasa”), Rønning’s rousing film gives sufficient breathing room to Trudy’s childhood years, establishing her world and closest kin with exquisite care: her hardworking, headstrong mother Gertrude (Jeanette Hain) who won’t let Trudy give up on her ocean-bound dreams, her stubborn but affectionate father Henry (Kim Bodbia) who works as a proud butcher, her brother Henry Jr., and most importantly, her doting sister Margaret, a fellow swimmer played enchantingly by Tilda Cobham-Hervey in Margaret’s older years.

Popular on Variety

The two sisters are joined at the hip, even though Margaret is the only swimmer of the family at first. Eager to join her sister’s ranks and refusing to let her illness define her, Trudy sings to her dad day and night to annoy him, and force him into acceptance that Trudy must swim no matter what, even if that means severe hearing loss in the long run as the doctors fear. Well, this critic found Trudy’s tireless off-key chanting adorable, but the trick designed to irritate Henry works all the same, and before we know it, he decides to teach Trudy how to conquer the ocean, just to keep her quiet.

It can’t be overstated how delightfully these scenes play, bested only by the ones that follow Trudy in her teenage years, with the young woman still fighting for a spot in the community pool. Her mother comes to the rescue and makes a deal with the no-nonsense coach Charlotte Epstein (Sian Clifford) — Trudy would feed the boiler by the indoor pool, and practice after hours. Slowly but surely, she proves herself to her coach, surpassing the rest of the girls while Margaret’s life settles into a more common reality of the era: a marriage arranged by parents. But Trudy’s star rises to no end. After an efficiently constructed montage of her wins and a brilliant “You Go Girl!” sequence that would be too cruel to spoil, she finally finds herself in the big leagues: first, at the Paris Olympics and then, facing her first attempt to swim across the channel. But these avenues add up to no more than a pair of false starts, opportunities derailed by toxic men who just can’t let women compete and win as equals.

Women have always had it much harder, and this fact is a well-depicted, often blistering thread that runs through “Young Woman and the Sea.” From the headlines of scandalized newspapers that critique women’s skin-baring swimsuits to the condescending remarks Trudy frequently fields, several tidbits in the story remind the viewer that it isn’t only the dangerous currents and waves that Trudy is swimming against. Then again, the film sometimes spells things out too much, self-consciously applying today’s temperaments to the past. In one scene, for instance, an adorable, wide-eyed little girl approaches Trudy and thankfully gushes, “Because of you, they let me swim.” This moment feels jarringly redundant given women paving the way for future generations is already at the heart and soul of the entire film, one that abundantly celebrates the spirit of sisterhood.

Still, no such misjudged stroke is significant enough to set “Young Woman and the Sea” off course. On land, Nora Takacs Ekberg’s intricate production design and Gabriele Binder’s convincing costumes snap the period into place with loving details. At sea, Úna Ní Dhonghaíle’s exacting editing and Oscar Faura’s crystal-clear cinematography coherently follow and represent the action as Trudy finally swims across the English Chanel alongside a guide boat steered by her singing sister, her ever-supportive father and an inspiring brand-new coach Bill Burgess (an often hilarious Stephen Graham), a men who successfully swam the length before and is unafraid to share his glory with Trudy.

That gorgeous third act plays as a riveting sequence that “Young Woman and the Sea” searingly charts, culminating in a final stretch during which Trudy swims through the dangerous shallows alone and in the dark. It’s no spoiler to say that she will make it — that’s history. But the real surprise here is the punch that Rønning manages to pack when the inevitable happens, an emotional feat that last year’s “Nyad” sorely lacked. In that, Trudy’s triumph — followed eagerly around the world, including by her mom and brother in NYC — feels no less magnificent than that famous moment in “Apollo 13” when Odyssey finally reconnects with Houston.

Throughout Rønning’s sophisticated film and alongside Ridley’s stunning performance — a career highlight for her — we all hold our collective breath and swim with Trudy. Talk about the kind of film they hardly ever make anymore.

Read More About:

Jump to Comments

‘Young Woman and the Sea’ Review: Daisy Ridley Stuns and Earns Your Tears in This Beautifully Classical Movie

Reviewed at AMC Lincoln Square, New York, May 28, 2024. MPA Rating: PG. Running time: 128 MIN.

  • Production: A Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures, Disney+ release of a Walt Disney Pictures presentation of a Jerry Bruckheimer Films production. Producers: Jerry Bruckheimer, Chad Oman, Jeff Nathanson. Executive Producers: John G. Scotti, Daisy Ridley, Joachim Rønning.
  • Crew: Director: Joachim Rønning. Screenplay: Jeff Nathanson. Camera: Oscar Faura. Editor: Úna Ní Dhonghaíle. Music: Amelia Warner.
  • With: Daisy Ridley, Tilda Cobham-Hervey, Stephen Graham, Kim Bodnia, Jeanette Hain, Glenn Fleshner, Sian Clifford, Christopher Eccleston.

More from Variety

Most Popular

Must Read

Sign Up for Variety Newsletters

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.We use vendors that may also process your information to help provide our services. // This site is protected by reCAPTCHA Enterprise and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Variety Confidential

A Variety and iHeartRadio Podcast

ncG1vNJzZmiukae2psDYZ5qopV9nfXOAjp%2BgpaVfp7K3tcSwqmixn6q7qHnWqKSapl2Wu6V506GcZquVlnqzsdWinLBllJa2tMWMq6CdpJWuenJ%2Bkm9nanFiZX9w